By MIKE PAUL
KUALA LUMPUR, Nov 17 — The KLSCAH land premium has become the latest flashpoint within the unity government, after Umno Youth chief Datuk Dr Akmal Saleh questioned how the amount payable for the Kuala Lumpur and Selangor Chinese Assembly Hall’s land was cut from an estimated RM4.67 million to a nominal RM1,000.
In a Facebook post, Akmal argued that setting a nominal premium only changes the amount paid, not the land’s assessed value, and asked Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department (Federal Territories) Hannah Yeoh to explain the basis for the reduction. He also challenged her to name a single plot of land in Kuala Lumpur that has no value.
What was approved
Hannah announced the decision at KLSCAH’s 103rd anniversary dinner on Saturday (Nov 14). She said the Federal Territories Land Committee approved the surrender and re-alienation of the land for institutional use on Sept 14, with a lease of up to 99 years.
An approval letter dated Oct 1 fixed the premium at RM1,000. According to Hannah, the total payable under the official land notice is RM5,011, covering the premium, the first year’s land rent and administrative charges, while annual land rent is set at RM3,151.
She said the approval followed Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim’s commitment to give special consideration to preserving the historic building after his visit during Chinese New Year celebrations on Feb 17.
Why the premium was reduced
Speaking at a press conference after the Federal Territories State Disaster Management Committee meeting on Monday (Nov 16), Hannah said the reduction reflected the change in the land’s status from commercial to institutional use.
“When the land status changes, its value is no longer the same as that of commercial land because it can no longer be developed for condominiums or shopping malls,” she said.
She added that the KLSCAH management had applied for the reduction because the building is a heritage structure with a long history, and the committee evaluating the application agreed to set the premium at RM1,000. The building was gazetted as a heritage site in 2007.
In a Facebook statement on Tuesday (Nov 17), Hannah said KLSCAH had voluntarily given up the potential to redevelop the site into high-rise condominiums or a shopping mall. She said the hall still pays quit rent to the land office, assessment tax to Kuala Lumpur City Hall (DBKL) and income tax to the Inland Revenue Board, and accused some critics of turning the matter into a racial issue.
Political backdrop
The exchange adds to recent friction between Umno and DAP leaders within the unity government, which has also seen Anthony Loke step down from the Cabinet and a public row over Ahmad Maslan’s pantun. Akmal maintained that the original valuation of RM4.67 million still stands, regardless of the amount actually paid.
Land matters in the capital, including premiums and land rent, are administered by the Federal Territories Director of Land and Mines Office.
What this means
For the public purse, the decision means the government collects RM5,011 upfront and RM3,151 a year in land rent for the site, instead of an estimated one-off premium of about RM4.67 million. For owners of heritage, community or religious buildings, the case shows that converting land to institutional status can lower the premium, but it also permanently limits how the land can be used. The government has not said whether the same approach will be applied to other heritage sites in Kuala Lumpur.
– TNS News
